Related Dilemmas:

How the Chips Fall

How does one find the moral courage to challenge company policy?

In Defense of Due Process

When is furthering your organization’s mission the wrong thing to do?

A Lack of Outrage

A young professional tries to understand management’s casual viewpoint in the face of unethical dealings.

Responsible for Restitution?

When a family foundation grows from private business, where is the demarcating line drawn?

When Somebody Else’s Right-versus-Wrong Decision puts you in a Right-versus-Right Dilemma

How to deal with a dishonest co-worker.

Archive IconView all dilemmas

Give Me a Break

Samuel approves leases for Bayside Properties, a real estate company. One day, Elaine, a real estate appraiser, approaches Samuel to inquire about leasing office space in one of the company’s buildings. Elaine has previously rented space in a Bayside building, but that building has been sold; Elaine needs to find new space at the end of her lease. Samuel would like to rent to Elaine—she is not only an ideal tenant with an excellent credit record with the company, but Samuel knows that Elaine is in the position to speak favorably to others about the company’s good service and careful maintenance of their buildings. In addition, Elaine is a close family friend.

Samuel has the perfect space for Elaine coming available just when she needs it. The problem is, rental rates have increased quite a bit since Elaine signed her last lease with Bayside, and it is more than she wants to pay. Elaine asks Samuel for a break on the rent. What should he do?

If you would like permission to distribute or reprint this resource please fill out the Permission Request Form by clicking here.

Read more dilemmas: Business Dilemmas

Note: This and other dilemmas on this site come to you without their real-life resolutions.  We encourage you to think for yourself about how you might resolve them, since the nature of each dilemma is highly individualistic.  In sharing these dilemmas, we do not endorse them in any way, but rather offer them for your consideration.